BETTER FLY THAN SAIL

 AUSTRALIA’S BORDER FARCE                     

A small group of presumed asylum seekers was reportedly discovered on the Kimberley coast last Friday. If correct then the much-spruiked cooperation between Indonesian naval authorities and the Australian Border Force allegedly protecting our shores has become a farce.  

Ten or more men who stepped onto the sovereign sands of their dream nation are said to have been arrested by a hundred ABF operatives rushed north at the weekend to staunch the invasion.  The prisoners were apparently whisked to Nauru for processing before refugee lawyers could blow in their ears.  

If the unwelcome arrivals are Chinese nationals as believed they'll probably be sent back to their homeland.  Runaways from the Middle Kingdom making it to the Lucky Country are rare. Past risk-takers have come from Iran, Afghanistan, Pakistan, India and Myanmar after spending stateless years in Indonesia, a nation that doesn't settle refugees.

About 12,000 are in this situation mainly hanging around Jakarta and surviving on handouts from the UN High Commission for Refugees.

In Australia there are now over 100,000 asylum seekers according to one report, with “2,000 new arrivals every month.”  These people are coming by air arousing little interest.

This month’s 10 undetected arrivals causing a media meltdown  came by sea - their number 0.05 per cent of those who use planes. The boat people were reported to have been found with no boat in sight  on the seashore near the old Truscott airfield in WA - the site of another landing last year.  It was built in 1944 as a heavy bomber base to raid Japanese positions in the Indonesian archipelago.

The jump-off points, of the alleged asylum seekers are unknown though some of the little marine lay-bys on Roti (sometimes spelt Rote)  Island - around 500 km north of the Kimberley seem likely.

The ABF has been crowing of its intensified aerial searches of the Arafura Sea since arrivals restarted last November, yet has missed three come-and-go ferries across an open ocean.  

This gives the lie to its website boast: 'Australia watches every boat' suggesting it can turn them back.  It can't even see them.

The ABF also claims problems in maintaining its pledge. In a Senate estimates hearing last year, Force Commissioner Michael Outram spoke of pilot shortages, issues with maintenance schedules and having to use Defence facilities in another bid for more money.

The unsubstantiated notion that “the ABF is aware smugglers have recently switched to valuable boats that can travel up to 20 knots” has been floated with favoured media by the ABF to excuse its incompetence.  Even the ABC has nudged the theory and increased the undetected boats to four.

Any speedboat would be expensive, sizeable and a standout at every traditional port around the Indonesian archipelago; most look more like junkyards than safe harbours.  Fast craft would have to be registered so police would know of their presence.  So would the envious local fishers keen to dob-in outsiders.

The unproven theory suggests a costly well-organised operation run by international crime syndicates bypassing, or in league with, Indonesian authorities.  A sophisticated show rather than the ill-planned journeys of the past when boats have broken down, lost their way or run out of food and water.

Formed nine years ago when Tony Abbott was PM by bonding Immigration and Customs under the super-ministry of Home Affairs, the ABF considers itself a smug secret service with a duty of keeping the Australian public blinkered.

The favourite rebuff for  inquiring journos - including your correspondent - is no comment about 'on-water matters' and 'ongoing operations.'  This silly policy meant Australian news outlets reported 10, 12 and 15 intruders jumping off the latest mystery boat. (Ten seems the right figure.)

State police investigating serious crimes are usually far more forthcoming with facts for the press because they rely on public support for information.

The reporter flick-away technique was first used in the Abbott / Morrison era. The policy remains in place under Anthony Albanese allowing the agency and its 6,000 operatives to escape independent media scrutiny.

The reasoning is that publicity will encourage people smugglers to sell passages as though the criminals rely on factual stories rather than hoaxes.  The reality is that the ABF’s failure to spot ferries is a far bigger magnet.

The ABF claims its officials have been working with Indonesian authorities to publish info and running community sessions warnings of the risks facing people smugglers and their cargoes.

Maritime dangers stressed include shipwrecks, drownings, hull leaks and engine breakdowns. Land hazards are prowling crocs, getting lost and perishing through thirst. Penalties for organisers include  time in prisons serving ample food and good health care, conditions far superior to those in Indonesian jails.

In touring the eastern islands closest to Australia, your correspondent has yet to encounter any fisher who says he (Indonesian women rarely work as crew) has attended such sessions known as sosialisasi.

That doesn't mean the info distribution hasn't happened, only that it's had little impact.

The boats haven’t been stopped and more than 60 aliens have made it undetected - probably with the help of Indonesian seafarers - over the past five months suggesting the risks get rewarded.

The Opposition has predictably blamed Albanese for the latest arrivals when the real culprit is the ABF’s inattention. Albanese has responded by saying border control principles established by the Abbott government remain in place.

They shouldn't. It's time the  Government rethought its inheritance and set up a department that can do the job - and treat Australians like adults who can be  told what's happening.  That’s part of being in  a democratic society.

##

 First published in Michael West Media, 12 April 2024:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

SEA SLUG VIAGRA

 SEX AND THE SEA:  SLUGS NOT FOR SHARING       

Australians ended 2023 to shock-horror reports of "the largest cohort of foreign fishers to be detained in over a decade."  The Return of the Living Dread? Not quite - just  30 Indonesian trepangers.

They were seized by the paranoid Australian Border Force (ABF) - and disappeared.  The managed media has reported one side of the story.  Duncan Graham tells another:

Patahudin Sijaya finds Australians hard to understand, though not for want of trying.

The 49-year-old Indonesian skipper of a hefty 25-metre timber fishing boat is a friendly guy hampered by a lack of English. Despite our self-awarded reputation for mateship the ABF crews he’s encountered aren't friendly, waving their neighbours away as their bobbing craft come close in disputed waters.

That puzzles the ‘Captain’ as he’s known in his home port of Palalakkang near Makassar on the Indonesian island of Sulawesi.  He told Michael West Media what he wanted to yell across the waves:

“Hey, what’s the matter with you Australians?  You’ve got so many fish why don’t you let us stay for a few days, then we can leave with a full hold?  If you don’t like that idea get going and catch them yourselves.  You treat them like pets.”

Only weirdos could find trepang, aka sea cucumbers, cuddly. They're not fish but tropical reef and ocean-floor scavengers classified as echinoderms, Greek for 'hedgehog skin'.

That explains why predators retreat, though not humans. Plain thinkers see an anal discharge but imagineers reckon they look phallic so must be an aphrodisiac.

Although no evidence upholds this illogicality, limp men are keen to pay more than $300 a kilo.   

The commerce predates James Cook by three centuries, maybe more.  Unlike the British settler fleets the all-bloke crews were and are sail-ins, sail-outs.  That's still the situation.  Indonesians cheerfully admit to rindu kampung halaman - homesickness.

Abundance

In a high-wall yard in the village of Galesong is a sight to raise joy in the impotent. Hundreds of trays of gutted trepang drying in the sun. Some weigh more than a kilo, others are small and black like shriveled snakes.

“They’re brought here  to be processed and then sent to East Java for export.  I don’t know their origins,” said village leader Muhammad Ikhsan.   “So many varieties, no shortage.”

When Australia became a Federation it brought the omnipresent fear of the Asian Invasion that persists still.  The first laws against "poachers" were passed in 1906 because the foreigners were said to be "too industrious".  

In 1974 the Whitlam Government started trying to get serious about Asia.  A new sea boundary was set  telling fishers what boats they could use.  Sails OK, motors no.  

 Commented two legal researchers: “The prohibition against the use of technology has contributed to the deaths of numerous fishermen during cyclones. Instead of acting as a deterrent against fishing, (this) has simply increased the suffering of an already impoverished population.”

Fishers are penned into 50,000 square kilometres of the Timor Sea through a ‘Memorandum of Understanding’, tagged by pedestrian bureaucrats as the MoU Box.   Another error - it’s shaped like a jigsaw piece.

The deals are one-sided. Though the 'box' is 200 nautical miles north of Broome, it’s only 60  south of Indonesia's Rote Island.

Canberra’s sea grab surged ahead. In 1981 the Australian Fishing Zone was pushed out to 320 km. 'Total Exclusion Zones’ appeared on maps.

Though joint patrols are sometimes run Australia does the heavy policing. Indonesia has more compelling issues than helping  a neighbour nurture sea slugs.  

The arrangement stayed afloat till some skippers found ferrying asylum seekers paid better than harpooning trepang. The Boat People  scare hardened loose laws. Crews were jailed - often illegally - boats burned and their human cargo sent to Nauru.

That traffic seems to have lessened giving the ABF the chance to track trepangers.

The December catch followed an ABC TV Lateline programme featuring Australian authorities and high-tech fishers with steel boats venting their disquiet and voicing rumours of hidden mother ships.The views of the Indonesians weren’t included.

A Fisheries Management spokesperson told MWM: "The Kimberley Marine Park has seen a significant increase in illegal foreign fishing since July 2023 (and) many Indonesian fishing vessels intercepted." No data was supplied.

The Diver’s Tale

Diver Sukri  surfaced twice in the last decade to find a boat waiting with men in uniform.  He was not afraid.

“I love Australia,” he said, “everyone was kind and polite.  They gave me regular health checks, plenty of food and even money when I was deported.”  

His overseas adventures excite his  mates on Barrang Lompo a half square kilometre island an hour from Makassar.  

It’s the largest homeport for trepang fishers in Eastern Indonesia with a fleet of around 100 diesel-powered timber boats. Most are leased so burning or confiscating by the ABF rarely impacts crews.

Sukri said he was warned of jail if he gets caught again.  He doesn't fear the shame of imprisonment so the threat is useless. To make it work we'd need to starve and torture inmates in isolation cells like  the system in Syria.

“Catches are down but that could be the weather,” he said. “I’ve just earned Rp 14 million ($1,350) working Indonesian waters for 40 days.  That’s good.” (The minimum monthly wage in Jakarta is $500, less in the provinces.)

No Buyer’s Remorse

Yusran's under-house store, also on Barrang Lompo, has eight 50 kg Styrofoam boxes of fresh salted trepang. He said he paid a captain $80 a kilo, down  $20 from a month ago.  The trade is reportedly worth $300 million a year, a figure that seems too low.

“I sell to the processors and the trepang eventually go to China,” he said.  “Prices vary according to supply and demand.”

Sydney University research suggests trepang numbers are falling on the Great Barrier Reef. There are no reports of Indonesians working Queensland waters.

The 30 men caught in December were sent to a WA detention centre.  The Indonesian Consul General in Perth said it  hadn’t been told the men’s homeports and names, suggesting Jakarta was being kept out of the loop.

The fear factor

The story broke courtesy of the ABF feeding understaffed newsrooms with its version of events plus video.The 6,000-strong ABF is a third force extra to the police and defence. Some officers carry guns. It was set up in 2015.

 It  keeps its doings sub rosa, even though it operates in a democracy. To ease any distress citizens might suffer on discovering sea-slug gatherers stepping ashore the ABF release added: "The Australian community can be assured these fishers will be detected and our response will be resolute."

It didn’t say whether the men had been charged, and if so which court and when.  MWM has been vigorously seeking answers.

 Habeas corpus (produce the person) is a fundamental principle of Australian law requiring every prisoner to be brought before a court.  If  illegally held  they must be released. A prisoner has to apply so needs legal help.  The men were picked up in the Silly Season, not ideal to activate legal aid.

ABF refused to take questions; the government’s Fisheries Management Authority would only say “these matters are currently under investigation …(no) further comment.”

From other sources and after a fortnight of nagging MWM can now reveal that 15 men have been deported and the rest are scheduled to fly in a few days.    So no public scrutiny and no political outrage.  Is that how we want our agencies to operate?

Chance to fix

Like pollution and global warming, conservation is an international concern. Trepang wriggle across sovereign borders, so their carers and catchers better think outside the box.  

The election of a new president this year gives Canberra a chance to reset relations. That includes negotiating better ways to preserve marine life without demonising and jailing poor fishers following orders and spending millions to process and deport the naughties.

Maintaining the present policy may keep the ‘Indonesian invaders’ story alive in the mainstream media - but who benefits from continually bashing that drum of amorality?

 

Duncan Graham has an MPhil degree, a Walkley Award, two Human Rights Commission awards and other prizes for his radio, TV and print journalism in Australia. He lives in East Java.

First published in Michael West Media , 24 January 2024:  https://michaelwest.com.au/indonesian-boat-people-scare-just-fishermen/?utm_source=newsletter&utm_medium=email&utm_term=2024-01-24&utm_campaign=Michael+West+Media+Weekly+Update

##