The shape of the world a generation from now will be influenced far more by how we communicate the values of our society to others than by military or diplomatic superiority. William Fulbright, 1964

Friday, September 30, 2005



Is the shortest distance between two points always a straight line? Not in the world of international shipping.

Which comes first – port or freight? It’s a question much like the chicken and the egg.

These and other conundrums have been plaguing the mind of Australian transport engineer John Hile for several years as he’s pondered the biggest question of all:

How can trade between Indonesia and Australia be boosted and made more efficient?

In mid September a ship carrying 55 containers of paper products from East Java quietly sailed directly from Surabaya to Darwin as a trial run for what may become a new regular service. The big boxes were then put on a train and trucks destined for shops in the capital cities of the southern states.

From go to whoa the journey took about eight days, around one third of the time it normally takes on the traditional sea route Surabaya – Singapore – Melbourne.

To the layperson the logistics look clear enough; why send goods north to Singapore so they can then be sent south to Australia?

But of course it’s not that simple, as Hile, the landbridging manager for Australian freight company Toll North, explained:

“Surabaya has traditionally been a feeder port for the hub of Singapore. Containers are offloaded there and then mixed with others destined for Australia,” he said.

“Australia’s major population centres are on the south-east corner of the continent. Darwin may be a lot closer to Indonesia, but it’s a tiny city and hasn’t been a calling port for ships from Singapore.”

It’s not just Hile who’s trying to alter the shape of international trade. In late September a team from the Northern Territory Government, Australian freight carriers and train operators were in Surabaya trying to persuade shippers to change their routes.

Last year more than one million TEUs left Surabaya’s container terminal. (A TEU is the unpronounceable industry term for a “Twenty-foot Equivalent Unit”.) The port at Tanjung Perak could handle double this load.

Economies of scale are pushing the shipping industry towards even bigger vessels. The monsters now carrying 8,000 TEUs will soon be dwarfed by ships with a capacity of 12,500. And of course they’ll need deeper harbors, more cranes and bigger ports to unload.

To make a Surabaya-Darwin connection viable exporters need to know that a scheduled freight service would be departing Indonesia’s second biggest port every week.

But without subsidies or guaranteed loadings a shipping company would be reluctant to initiate a regular sailing in the hope that freight will magically appear.

So the Australians spent time trying to stitch deals with shippers and lobbying local manufacturers. Many were among the 230 delegates from more than 25 nations at the ASEAN Ports and Shipping Conference in Surabaya

The Aussie’s arguments were based on savings through the opening last year of the new rail line. This links Darwin to Adelaide 3,000 km to the south, and the East-West network to all State capitals.

There is also an all-weather highway between Darwin and Adelaide open to road trains, and the port of Darwin is being massively upgraded.

“We’re not trying to take over existing shipping lines to Eastern Australia,” said John Parkes, general manager for international marketing of Freightlink, the operators of the north-south rail line. “We’re offering an alternative route.”

But his attempted appeasement of the big time freight shifters who snap their fingers at trade movements worth millions was undermined when he revealed ambitions to shift more than 350 containers out of Darwin on every train.

If successful the ports in Sydney, Melbourne, Adelaide, Brisbane and Fremantle would see a significant downturn in business. Clearly some noses would be put out of joint.

Already the Australian media has carried stories of the high cost of the rail link and importers preferring to use trucks. Construction faults on the Darwin wharf have also made the industry edgy about shifting from the tried and trusted ways of taking goods the long way round.

But the Australian hustlers in East Java flicked away such naysaying as “politics”, and pushed on with their salespitch.

There may not be much romance in a long steel box which looks the same in Antwerp or Zanzibar but the enthusiastic Australians made the business of picking up and plonking down lots of TEUs sound like one great adventure.

“Change is always difficult but this new route through Darwin will happen because the commercial realities will make it happen,” said Hile.

“At the moment Indonesia is no better off than China or India in getting its products into Australia through the current trade routes.

“East Java has a huge industrial capacity, much of it under-utilised and with a low-cost skilled labor force. In the country next door is a major market. Australia has a tiny manufacturing industry and not enough workers. The potential for Surabaya is huge. (See sidebar)

“There’s a huge push to have this going within six months – and we will be successful.”


The dream of a speedy link between Surabaya and Australia has long eluded transport planners who have been working for decades to get a direct transport route opened.

Australia exports goods worth about AUD 3,410 million to Indonesia and ranks at number six in the list of suppliers to Indonesia. Top of the list is Singapore followed by Japan, China, the US and Thailand.

Australia imports goods worth AUD 3,318 million from Indonesia. Apart from petroleum products, paper and timber are in demand.

Australia also exports petroleum products to the archipelago along with minerals, live animals and primary produce.

It’s difficult to stuff a steer into a container, but minerals like gold, aluminium ingots and copper are put in containers. So is cotton. Only unrefined minerals like iron ore and grains are shipped in bulk.

Australia is number ten in the list of destinations for Indonesian goods. Most go to Japan and the US.

Indonesia is a major exporter of paper products to Australia. If you’re a journalist or secretary Down Under the chances are you’ll be taking notes on a pad made in East Java, using an Indonesian pen and maybe sitting at a wooden desk crafted in the archipelago.

Meanwhile their counterparts in this country are chewing on Australian steak washed down with a tangy fruit juice.

And the probability is high that all are wearing clothes made in booming China whose ports are already handling more than 61 million TEUs.

(First published in The Jakarta Post 30 September 05)


jon said...

I am trying to find metal roofing prices people and found your blog while searching. I totally agree with that...

Dave said...

That's an awesome article! I'm going to have to bookmark you.

I have a ##KEYWORD## site. It pretty much covers ##KEYWORD## related stuff.

Dave said...

Finding community college scholarship information is a difficult process. Thanks for helping others find more information about community college scholarship.

Davecommunity college scholarship

Christine said...

Hi Duncan,

Im doing a study to have adirect shipping from Australia to Surabaya.
Thank you for the nice article.

prolix said...

Last 2 weeks i was told by my bos that i'll be going for a business trip. The location is, Baltimore, i am so excited about the trip. But, somehow, there is also "a butterfly in my stomach" feeling in me.Merbau Australia